Somers' Maggie May's Not Your Typical Frozen Yogurt Shop

  • Comments (5)
Margaret "Maggie" Nader works at IBM as a sales executive. She has worked there for 33 years. Photo Credit: Brian Donnelly
Maggie Nader demonstrates how to make an Apple Pie Crepe. Photo Credit: Brian Donnelly
Maggie and Peter's son, Michael, shares their entrepreneurial spirit and helped get Maggie May's up and running in 2013. Photo Credit: Brian Donnelly
Maggie Nader grew up in Yonkers. Photo Credit: Brian Donnelly

GOLDEN'S BRIDGE, N.Y. – The self-serve frozen yogurt fad is likely here to stay, but Maggie Nader said she has put the service back into self-serve, while providing a healthy alternative.

The Pound Ridge entrepreneur always knew she wanted to open a shop. Maggie May’s, in the Golden's Bridge Shopping Center, opened one year ago selling frozen yogurt and smoothies. It has since added juice drinks and crepes. Most recently they added breakfast crepes, which is scrambled egg with spinach or cheese.

“With a self-serve yogurt shop people come in, they get their yogurt, they walk out,” she said. “We’re more service oriented. We get to know our customers. We talk to them. We make certain recommendations on certain juices depending on how they feel.”

Nader grew up in Yonkers and spent about 20 years in Katonah, where she raised three sons and two daughters with her husband, Patrick. They now live in Pound Ridge, where their youngest, Patrick, goes to Fox Lane High School.

The “juice bar” offers light concoctions that Patrick said some customers use to cleanse. Others order the fruit or protein smoothies, which Maggie Nader said many customers drink in place of a sandwich for lunch. The protein smoothies are made with either whey protein or soy.

“That’s the thing, we have something for everyone,” she said.

In addition to the healthy choices, customers can throw some toppings on frozen yogurt for that self-serve flare.

Like Maggie May’s, JJ’s Scoop House in Yorktown offers sweet treats and health juices and smoothies under the same roof. Owner Justin Fagan, of Yorktown, operates the ice cream side of the store, on 315 Kear St. His wife, Ghenya Gorbatko, takes care of the healthy food side, which will open in its own location across the street in the spring. Trail Side Café offers juices, smoothies, salads, soups and gluten-free baked goods.

Fagan moved to Yorktown from New York City, where he said one can find healthy food on every block. He said he and his wife hope to bring that to northern Westchester. 

Maggie Nader said yogurt is half the calories of ice cream, which is why people are so drawn to it.

“It was always my intention that when I opened up Maggie May’s in Goldens Bridge that we would not be the typical yogurt store,” she said.

  • 5

Comments (5)


What happened to the store in Pound Ridge ?


Hello Geerge,

The store in Pound Ridge closed. Please come and visit us at our store in Goldens Bridge right next door to the Post Office. You can also "like" us on our Facebook page:


I love Maggie May's in Goldens Bridge . Great addition to the area. Great Yogurt and awesome crepes!!!


If you are mentioning the frozen yogurt stores in Westchester then Yogolicious should be in this article. Jen Paternostro has expanded into 2 other stores (Briarcliff on North State Road and Harrison) after opening the first Yogolicious in Pleasantville in a very short time. No surprise at the quick growth as they have the best yogurt (<3 berry tart) and ice cream too. Jen is one of the most amazing people - kind and beautiful inside and out. She features logos from all the local schools inside her store making sure all feel welcome and connecting with the community. Love the ipads on the counters for kids. It's so great to have a fresh, healthy snack and a nice spot to sit and enjoy it!


Interesting timing...she's out of business n Pound Ridge

In Other News


Accidents Result In Delays On Hutch, 9A, Major Deegan


Tag Sales In And Around Somers


Westchester Will Forfeit $5.2M In Housing Grants